March Playboy Magazine Investigation Raises Disturbing Questions Regarding Diagnosis and Treatment of Post Traumatic Stress Diso
12 Febrero 2007 - 10:46AM
PR Newswire (US)
Article Finds Politics, Budget Constraints and Lack of Manpower to
Blame NEW YORK, Feb. 12 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- In an extensive,
months-long investigation, "The Real Cost of War," in Playboy
magazine's March issue (on newsstands and at
http://www.playboydigital.com/ Friday, February 9), journalist Mark
Boal discovers American troops fighting in Iraq and Iraq war
veterans are not receiving the mental health care they deserve,
specifically when it comes to the diagnosis and treatment of post
traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Boal spoke with numerous mental
health experts, government sources and former military personnel
who paint a disturbing picture about the government's handling of
PTSD. Boal found that the Department of Defense (DOD) diagnoses
about 2,000 cases of PTSD a year. Yet according to a landmark study
conducted by Army researchers and published in The New England
Journal of Medicine, PTSD rates for soldiers in Iraq and
Afghanistan are running between 10 and 15 percent. That means one
would expect to see the military diagnosing 13,000 to 20,000 cases
of PTSD. Former government officials agree there is a problem.
"PTSD is being underdiagnosed on a fairly wholesale level," says
Dr. Robert Roswell, a former undersecretary at the U.S. Department
of Veterans Affairs (VA). But why? According to sources in the
Pentagon and former officials of the VA, doctors working for the VA
and DOD are being pressured to limit diagnoses of PTSD in order to
save the military money and manpower, reports Boal. Budget
pressures may be the motivation to discourage diagnoses of PTSD,
according to the article, which reports that when the DOD submitted
a war budget to Congress, the line item for mental health
casualties was simply left blank. "DOD never prepared for a long
war; it never prepared for an occupation," says one senior
congressional staffer. "Now we're seeing the third thing it didn't
anticipate: what to do with the soldiers when they come home. Now
they really don't have the money." Boal discovered politics may
also be a factor. "The soldier has tremendous symbolic power in
American politics. Healthy, happy soldiers bespeak a just war. Like
the amputees and flag-draped coffins the administration hides from
public view, such soldiers are antithetical to the hawkish goal of
mitigating the costs of the conflict," writes Boal. "The critical
difference is that mental illness isn't always obvious and is
therefore easier to sweep under the rug." As one congressional
staffer puts it, "It's much easier to deny the reality of mental
illness than it is to deny the spinal cord injury of some guy
sitting in a wheelchair." When questioned for the piece, Pentagon
and VA officials vigorously denied there is a policy to
underdiagnose PTSD. "That would be immoral and unethical," says Dr.
Michael Kilpatrick, the assistant secretary of defense for troop
readiness. Officials attribute the low rates of diagnosis to a
reluctance on the part of military doctors to "stigmatize the
person or bring harm to their careers" by labeling them with PTSD
according to Lieutenant Colonel Dr. Charles Engel, the director of
the deployment health clinic center at Walter Reed Medical Center.
"It's out of respect for the patient that they don't make the
diagnosis." Dr. Sally Satel, a psychiatrist and adviser to
President Bush on mental health issues views PTSD this way: "I'm
not saying PTSD doesn't exist, but it's gotten out of hand. I mean,
if you see a lot of action and then you come home you have a hard
time walking your dog by the bushes at night, maybe you just avoid
the bushes." Boal's article follows the case of Private Jacob
Burgoyne, whose story suggests PTSD is more complicated than simply
avoiding the bushes. According to Adam Koroll, a former National
Guardsman serving as a mental health nurse in Iraq, he diagnosed
Burgoyne as having PTSD and says higher officials ignored his order
to evacuate Burgoyne to a psychiatric hospital. Koroll details how
Burgoyne was instead released to return home after fighting in
Iraq, visited an Army hospital where he talked briefly with an Army
psychiatrist, then stabbed a fellow soldier to death two days
later. He is currently serving 20 years in prison for murder. Mark
Boal's article "Death and Dishonor," also about the Iraq war, was
published in Playboy magazine in 2004 and adapted for the upcoming
film In the Valley of Elah. Playboy Enterprises is a brand-driven,
international multimedia entertainment company that publishes
editions of Playboy magazine around the world; operates television
networks and distributes programming globally; owns Playboy.com, a
leading men's lifestyle and entertainment web site; and licenses
the Playboy trademark internationally for a range of consumer
products and services. DATASOURCE: Playboy Enterprises CONTACT:
Linda Marsicano of Playboy Enterprises, +1-312-373-2447, or Web
site: http://www.playboydigital.com/
Copyright